Ditch the Vanity Metrics: What Smart Marketers Track Instead

In tighter economies, marketers are under pressure to prove value fast. But proving value doesn’t just mean launching more campaigns. It means measuring the right outcomes. Too often, we default to vanity metrics: flashy numbers like impressions, likes, or page views that look impressive on a dashboard but don’t say much about real business results.

Those metrics might offer a surface-level snapshot of reach, but they rarely reflect whether your audience is actually paying attention, taking action, or moving down the funnel. And in 2025, with performance scrutiny at an all-time high, that disconnect can be costly.

The Problem with Vanity Metrics

Let’s be clear: metrics like impressions and views have a place in measurement strategy. But when they’re the only numbers in focus, brands risk missing the full picture. A video ad might generate 1 million views, but how many viewers watched past the first three seconds? How many were in your target demographic? Did they recall the brand message later? Did they convert?

According to Nielsen, only 36% of digital ad impressions are actually viewed by a human for more than one second. That means the majority of so-called reach may not be reach at all. And while that might be fine in a brand awareness campaign, it’s not enough when your CFO is asking which channels are actually driving revenue.

Reframing Success with Smarter KPIs

To build more meaningful measurement strategies, advertisers are increasingly shifting their focus toward deeper performance metrics—those that better reflect attention, action, and outcomes. Here are the categories leading marketers are prioritizing in 2025:

1. Attention Metrics

Traditional viewability standards are being replaced by attention-based metrics that account for time spent, interaction levels, and even facial or gaze tracking in some environments. Platforms like TikTok, YouTube, and newer attention-optimization tools are surfacing data on scroll speed, sound-on rates, and completion quality.

Research from Lumen shows that attention metrics correlate three times more strongly with brand recall than viewability does. That means if your creative is actually capturing attention, it’s more likely to stick—and more likely to drive future behavior.

2. Brand Lift and Favorability

Brand lift studies, often conducted through platforms like Meta or YouTube, measure shifts in brand perception after exposure to an ad. Key metrics include ad recall, message association, favorability, and purchase intent.

Even when direct conversions aren’t possible (think CPG or pharma), brand lift provides evidence that your campaign is moving the needle. According to a Kantar study, strong creative can drive up to a 25-point lift in ad recall and a 13-point lift in brand favorability.

3. Cost Per Incremental Outcome

Rather than simply tracking conversions, advanced measurement strategies now focus on incremental results—the conversions that would not have happened without the ad. This includes cost per incremental visit, cost per lift in awareness, or cost per incremental sale.

Why does this matter? Because not all conversions reflect the same level of influence. Some ads reinforce existing intent, while others spark discovery or move a customer closer to purchase. The most impactful campaigns don’t just chase easy wins—they drive meaningful engagement across the entire funnel, whether that’s acquiring new customers, accelerating decision-making, or deepening loyalty.

4. Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)

Short-term campaigns often focus on immediate returns, but CLV allows marketers to understand the long game. By measuring how much value a customer brings over time, you can better assess which acquisition channels drive the highest quality traffic—not just the cheapest leads.

A recent McKinsey study found that companies using CLV-based targeting improved return on ad spend by 10% to 25% compared to those using short-term conversion data alone. It’s a reminder that the best metrics often extend beyond the initial campaign window.

5. Funnel Progression 

Instead of obsessing over final conversions, track how users move through your funnel: site visits, product page views, email signups, repeat engagement, and ultimately, purchase or lead generation.

These mid-funnel metrics help diagnose where campaigns are falling short and where to double down. For example, if your click-through rate is high but bounce rate is even higher, you may need better landing page alignment. Funnel metrics create a clearer map of what’s working—and what isn’t.

6. Platform-Specific Outcomes

Every channel has its own strengths — and its own rules of engagement. That means traditional KPIs like CTR or last-click attribution don’t always apply.

• On streaming audio, a listener might never click, but they may hear your full ad and then search for your brand later. Metrics like listen-through rate, brand lift, and playlist context provide stronger signals of success.
  
• On Connected TV, where there’s no clickable CTA, completion rate, household reach, and co-viewing rates give a better read on effectiveness.
  
• On retail media, in-cart attribution, incremental lift, and sales velocity are often more meaningful than impressions alone.
  

That’s where smarter measurement tools come in. Digilant helps clients connect these channel-specific metrics into one performance framework — so you can track what actually matters without comparing apples to oranges.

The Role of Creative in Measurement

Let’s not forget one key variable in all of this: creative quality. The smartest metrics in the world can’t save an ad that isn’t relevant, memorable, or engaging.

Google research shows that marketers who test just one additional creative element in a campaign see 3 times more conversions on average. Whether that’s a new call to action, a different visual cue, or even a refined headline, testing and iteration are core to performance success.

Creative strategy and measurement strategy go hand in hand. Track what matters. But also, build content that’s worth measuring.

Rethinking What Success Looks Like

Not every campaign needs to optimize for bottom-of-funnel conversions. Sometimes your goal is education. Sometimes it’s brand equity. Sometimes it’s a consideration. But no matter the goal, your metrics should match the moment.

In a climate where every line item is scrutinized, smarter measurement is your competitive edge. Skip the vanity numbers. Focus on attention, outcomes, and value—and you’ll have the data you need to make every dollar work harder.

Want More Strategies Like This?

The pressure to prove ROI is not going away. But the path to ROI doesn’t start with impressions—it starts with intention. The more intentional your metrics, the more strategic your decisions.

Want more tips, strategies, and measurement best practices?
Download the full eBook: Tough Times, Smarter Ads. Your guide to making performance count. No matter the market.